Keith Olbermann:  The Great Distraction

Keith Olbermann weighed in on Countdown last night with some of his inimitable common sense. Take a listen.

As James Carville pointed on CNN’s Situation Room yesterday per Hotline:

“It is much easier to say, I botched a joke, than to say, I botched a war. And he was very frank. ... He gave an explanation. And, as I say, Senator Kerry is one of the great war heroes to ever serve in the Congress. He has about a 100 percent record when it comes to the veterans. So, I don’t understand exactly what the problem is. He didn’t owe anybody an apology. He owed an explanation” (“Situation Room,” CNN, 10/31).

 

104 Comments

New comments for this entry are closed.

Bravo to KO!

Posted by democrafty | 11/01/06, 07:25 AM EST

Uneducated Grunt
It just breaks my heart that they have the power to brainwash you like they have.  I read quite abit and feel I have a true sense of what really is going on with this war.  It is just not possible, completely impossible in fact,  that we have been told the truth.
Some day, I pray, you will see the big picture. As heartening as that must have been, a hug from an Iraqi citizen does not excuse this complete mess this administration has premeditatedly gotten us into.
When ALL the truths come out, when this is just in the history books…maybe you will be able to see it.
I pray you will still be here. I truly do.

Posted by Paula | 11/01/06, 07:30 AM EST

Uneducated Grunt:
Soldierswife:

Ahh, the Blue to Green Bonus… I haven’t taken it because I’m not in this for the money. I’m in it because I LOVE my country and I’ll use my intellegence to benefit it far better than I could use my strength. Plus, there’s nothing better than watching on the camera as a JDAM gets close enough to a terrorist that you can see he needs a shave…

Posted by Uneducated Grunt | November 1, 2006 12:25 PM


SO are YOU now saying that the Army is uneducated because you’d rather bein in the air force so you can use your intelligence???? Unbelievable . . . .

Posted by soldierswife | 11/01/06, 07:34 AM EST

Thanks for posting these remarks by Olbermann and Carville!

Olbermann will extend his reporting tonight (Wednesday), with a “Special Comment” on this issue. Don’t miss it!

Also, Carville’s comments to me have a special authority, as he himself is an ex-Marine. I suspect that he, like Kerry, like Murtha, and other vets, takes the chickenhawks personally. As they should.

Many thanks, Sen. Kerry, for the courage, spunk, and commitment you’ve brought to your campaign and fundraising for candidates all across this nation. We are behind you all the way. Keep telling the truth, , just as you have been.  The truth will prevail. So will you. And so will the Democrats on November 7.

Posted by mbk | 11/01/06, 07:35 AM EST

On Iraqi Orders, Bush Abandons American Soldier To Al-Sadr’s Militia
By Christy Hardin Smith @ 7:54 am


(Photo credit for this heartbreaking shot to Damir Sagolij/Reuters.)

I am shaking with rage at the moment.  American soliders do not abandon their own.  Unless, of course, someone orders them to do so.  Which is exactly what happened when the Bush Administration — via it’s envoy Zalmay Khalilzad — agreed to lift the eight day long blockade and search and rescue mission for the captured American soldier…on the demand and order of the Iraqi government.

You read me correctly, the US envoy in Iraq has decided that our US military personnel should take orders from the Iraqi government and abandon one of our soldiers to the Mahdi Army.  That this decision occurred abruptly after Stephen Hadley’s visit to Baghdad yesterday raises a whole host of questions in my mind — and the press had better damn well be asking for some answers from the Bush Administration today.

The move lifted a near siege that had stood at least since last Wednesday. U.S. military police imposed the blockade after the kidnapping of an American soldier of Iraqi descent. The soldier’s Iraqi in-laws said they believed he had been abducted by the Mahdi Army as he visited his wife at her home in the Karrada area of Baghdad, where U.S. military checkpoints were also removed as a result of Maliki’s action.

The crackdown on Sadr City had a second motive, U.S. officers said: the search for Abu Deraa, a man considered one of the most notorious death squad leaders. The soldier and Abu Deraa both were believed by the U.S. military to be in Sadr City.

The Bush Administration has been encouraging Iraqi-Americans to become more involved in the “liberation” of Iraq.  The American military needs more soldiers with regional language fluency, and Iraqi Americans have an understandable interest and personal stake — with many relatives still living in the war torn nation — in working to make things better.  The American soldier who was captured is of Iraqi-American descent, he was wearing the uniform of the United States…and we have abandoned him to Moqtada Al-Sadr’s Mahdi Army and Sadr City’s rage as of yesterday.

We do not abandon our own.

Unless, of course, you are the Bush Administration — which, apparently, has decided to let the Iraqi government start calling the shots for the US military.  I hear George Bush will be on Limbaugh’s show — wonder if he’ll be asked about his decision to abandon a US soldier to Al-Sadr’s militia, with their penchant for torture, on the orders of the Iraqi head of state?

The corporate media had better start asking questions about this, because the American military taking orders to abandon one of their own from a foreign government is something that every single person with friends and family in Iraq right now will want to know about…immediately.  How many American soldiers are we now willing to leave to the mercies of Al-Sadr’s Army and other torture-wielding militants with no love for the American military presence in the name of propping up Maliki’s government?  George Bush does not get a pass on this one.  Period.  The time for accountability is now.

A BOTCHED JOKE IS MEANINGLESS.

A BOTCHED WAR COSTS LIVES.

Posted by Ken | 11/01/06, 07:36 AM EST

Fantastic photo, Luis!  But tragic, so tragic…in John Kerry’s mind, at least.

Posted by Grandmother Jan | 11/01/06, 07:37 AM EST

Please John, just say you are sorry to the very few troops that might have been confused by all the hype about your comments about Bush being an idiot. You will get free air time to talk about all of Bush’s failed policies.  I have heard all you have said and I know their is a push to fight back.  But this is not the battle you want to fight.  They are saying on MSN and other sights that you are arragant and frankly as a democrat I   can see their point, meaning that perception see really more important than the truth with todays right winged media in control of most off what people see.

Posted by Denny | 11/01/06, 07:38 AM EST

Brainwashed?  Brainwashed?  I see.  Would being “brainwashed” explain why I was a registered Democrat for the first half-dozen or so years I could vote?  Perhaps it would explain why I voted for Gore in 2000?  You can read all you want, you can have a “sense” of what is going on… but it all means nothing until you’ve BEEN in it.  I see the big picture more than maybe anyone on this forsaken blog.  Was Iraq premeditated? Probably not.  But does that change the fact we’re there now?  No.  Does it change the fact we have a mission to complete?  No.  Does it change the fact that our best and brightest are over here, and we’re doing all we can to make sure their worst don’t come over there?  No.  I appreciate your prayers for me, and your hopes that I stick around… but my life means nothing to me if I don’t have a nation to go home to, and THAT is why I’m here.

Posted by Uneducated Grunt | 11/01/06, 07:39 AM EST

I don’t think that Sen. Kerry has to apologize for the ‘idea’ of the joke but since it was mis-spoken (as well as mis-quoted because of it) he needs to say something like, ” I apologize to any present or former GI who was given the impression that I thought she/he unintelligent.  What the joke was supposed to convey is that when you are given the privilige to go to college and don’t use it well, come out uninformed and bull-headed, you will get us into a war for no reason and kill a lot of valuable men and women”
Now, the White House spin doctors are going to have an even bigger field day…and even more distraction that leads this country away from the truth of this war.  The truth of the oil rich getting richer!  I usually vote Democrat and I am cringing today.  I want a STRONG and THOUGHTFUL team in place to get us a different sort of governing than we have today. An intelligent and well-spoken, calm and decisive “for the good of the real people” kind of government.  Is it ever going to happen?  Not with word fumbles like this one.  I am discouraged once again.  I don’t want these oil-loving, war-mongering, life-sucking people in the White House again.

Posted by Chris | 11/01/06, 07:42 AM EST

Don’t back down, Bush’s crew is trying any distraction from their record. I heard him say you called the troops stupid and he said the troops are neither stupid or cowards. Don’t let them get by with that.

What needs to be brought out is most of the people in the military are from groups who cannot afford to pay for college and others who join the Guard to supplement their incomes.

Posted by harold christenson | 11/01/06, 07:44 AM EST

I agree with Kerry the military has lowered the standards to enlist soldiers just to meet the quotas of this war. I have 15 years of service and have been deployed in 1991 and 2002. Which means I have lived thru the changes of the Army and I have watch this conflict turn into a war. Kerry hit it on the head if you don’t get an education the Army will offer you an enlistment bonus and a GED to go to Iraq

Posted by April Rife | 11/01/06, 07:47 AM EST

Murtha calls it like it is

http://thinkprogress.org/2006/11/01/murtha-kerry-iraq

Murtha: Kerry Flap ‘Just Distracting From The Real Issue, The War On The Ground’

Today on MSNBC, Rep. John Murtha (D-PA), a 26-year Marine Corps veteran, talked about the media flap over remarks by Sen. John Kerry (D-MA). Murtha said there is “no question in my mind that John Kerry supports the troops,” and that right-wing attacks on Kerry are “just distracting from the real issue: the war on the ground.
Watch it:

Posted by FrenchGirlFromMA | 11/01/06, 07:47 AM EST

harold christenson:

my husband is a college graduate and he joined after he got his degree because he wanted to serve his country. it was his choice. he has been in the army for 27+ years and loves every bit of it. he also has a purple heart (he was shot a year ago last june) so I don’t think you know what your talking about!!!

Posted by Sondra | 11/01/06, 07:52 AM EST

Newsweek: Kerry incident is bad for GOP
by zenbowl
Wed Nov 01, 2006 at 09:08:03 AM PST

The media backlash over the attack on Kerry has already begun. Witness: Newsweek

The risks for President Bush are greater than they are for Sen. Kerry, who may have suffered the deep embarrassment of falling into a familiar, self-made trap. But he leads nothing inside his party, sets no strategy and the Democrats can easily disown him—as several candidates have done by canceling events with him this week.

President Bush, on the other hand, enjoys no such luxuries. In fact, the concerted attack on Kerry—complete with White House and Republican National Committee press releases—threatens to undermine a central premise of the party’s strategy. For months on the campaign trail, GOP candidates have insisted the election isn’t a referendum on Bush or national politics; it’s a choice between two local contenders. The president may have diverted attention back onto Democrats, but he also turned the focus back on himself and the war.

For once, the GOP’s knee-jerk attack will have immediate bad consequences.

zenbowl’s diary :: ::

The whole piece is pretty interesting, and insightful. In addition to the idea that the American public generally dislikes Bush and the war, and anything that focuses attention on Iraq is bad for the president, I think, too, that, because the current election season, the average American is easily able to judge and dismiss ridiculous criticism.

That said, I’m glad John Kerry is retreating to his bunker for the next week.

Posted by Nik | 11/01/06, 07:53 AM EST

If nothing else, all these personal stories show how a great a need there is in this country for people to represent them, to tell their stories, to care about their lives and families.

Posted by kj | 11/01/06, 07:56 AM EST

What is it that you don’t understand about the English language and the republican party? During a campaign you cannot give them anymore fuel for their corruptive campaign than they already use. It astounds me that you would not go on tv and explain your comments to those who misinterpeted what you said. All of us who are Democrats realize what you meant but that is not how it sounded. So do us all a favor tell the American public and our troops exactly what you meant as to at least get this out of the campaign. There are enough mud slinging and disgusting things going on in this campaing without this. Just explain yourself and lets win back both houses.
We love our troops. Make sure they are constantly reminded of that. They need our support even if we do not agree with Bush’s handling of this war.
Please help us win this election and then move on to the presidential election later. This one is the one we need to win now.
Posted by Leslie who has loved ones in Iraq.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


swallopw your prid

Posted by leslie notargiacomo | 11/01/06, 07:57 AM EST

Was anyone watching Tony Snow just now. I don’t have a recording but I believe that Tony Snow was suggesting that Kerry should apologize saying that “it was a mistake, that he had a silver star and he had ‘did his time’” Why would Tony Snow refer to being in the military as “doing time” which in my mind is what people refer to prison as.

Anyone catch this?

-jake

Posted by Jake | 11/01/06, 07:58 AM EST

Reality check—this distraction and smear against Senator Kerry is not working.  I just talked to a Bush voter (yeah, a real one as opposed to the fake Democrats who are feigning outrage here), and she is going to vote straight ticket Dem here in Virginia.  Her feelings—vote them ALL out.  And she enthusiastically voted for Bush.  So get real people, this story is a nonstory.  The story upthread, however, about the Sadr City siege and withdrawal is major news.

Also noticed that the Allen brawl is now the front page story on AOL—that’s a more accurate depiction of what the Republicans feel about dissenters, especially dissenting veterans.

Posted by beachmom | 11/01/06, 08:00 AM EST

I don’t believe that Sen. Kerry needs to apologize for anything. I understood him to say that if you don’t do well in school (like Bush didn’t) you may end up stuck in a place like Iraq (like Bush is).

Posted by Rod | 11/01/06, 08:01 AM EST

Well said, April Rife.

Most people in middle-class suburbia do not even realize who’s getting recruited for our military…and it’s not our children or neighbors.  Reasonable people know exactly what Kerry meant, that our inner-city youth are the most attractive targets to the armed forces from a recruitment standpoint.

Posted by Cucamonga Fish | 11/01/06, 08:01 AM EST

Perhaps John Kerry could use this example in clarifying his comments.  Has Jenna enlisted? Has Barbara enlisted? Has Pierce Bush enlisted? Has George P. Bush enlisted? Have Joe Lieberman’s kids enlisted? No, no, no, no, no.  Elitist Republicans and de-facto Republicans stay the course with other people’s kids while their own kids go shopping and cavort around the globe.

Posted by Joe | 11/01/06, 08:09 AM EST

Paula,
THEY have the power to brainwash?
You’ve been watching too much TV, Paula or reading too many conpiracy books.  Close the book and (harsh is it may be) connect with the real world.

There is no diabolical plot being hatched by the BIG BAD GUYS that you have conjured up in your little make believe world.  Please don’t share your delusional conception of reality with us.

You talk as if you can see the “bigger picture”.

How ironic that my viewpoint is exactly just the opposite of yours and I would use the same words for my viewpoint.  And that is, YOU don’t see the “bigger picture”.

Hiistory WILL tell us what was right.  But I don’t need to wait for history to tell me what is right.  And you won’t see it in your paranoid fogged brain.
This is not a novel with a twist ending.
It’s basically a Holy War . . in that IS a war of religions.  A religion that wants to dictate how you should think, dress, feel, live and die versus all other religions.
And they are so radical in their belief that they want to kill you.  And they are willing to die to kill you.
The question is are you willing to die for your beliefs.  If not, are you willing to support someone who will die for you?

[Edited.  Please be respectful of the views of others.  Thanx.]

Posted by Ken Rogers | 11/01/06, 08:10 AM EST

Beachmom wrote: (yeah, a real one as opposed to the fake Democrats who are feigning outrage here)
——

Excuse me?  I am 42 years old and have been a registered Democrat since the age of 18.  I have voted in EVERY local, state, and national election since that time.  I completely resent your tone and words!  God forbid that someone disagrees with you and is in your own party. 

[Edited.  Please be respectful of the opinions of others.  Thanx.]

Posted by Jim Waid | 11/01/06, 08:21 AM EST

It is Goerge W Bush who owes our troops an apology!!  He led them into a war that was justified on lies and deceptions and without a clear understanding what they would be facing Iraq.  His actions have killed over 3000 Americans and countless Iraqis and maimed thousands more.  And he still has no plan for how to correct the mess he created.  When you think about it, he should consider himself fortunate to get away with just an apology!

Posted by Jack | 11/01/06, 08:21 AM EST

I have a new post up on Liberal Values, primarily on the reaction to the attacks on John Kerry:

http://liberalvaluesblog.com/?p=528

Posted by Ron Chusid | 11/01/06, 08:23 AM EST

As a VietNam vet, and a registered voting Democrat, I have to weigh in on this. If John Kerry apologizes, he will once again be “swiftboated” by those who have never worn a military uniform or, when they did, chose not to keep their comittments. And, once again, the Democratic party is showing that they lack the courage of their convictions by demanding that Kerry apologize, when they should be standing in Kerry’s support.
And I don’t believe that Kerry was wrong. The military has already severely lowered (read “dumbdowned”) the requirements and expectations for recruits and, after the 2006 elections, if the Republicans retain any kind of power, you can rest assured that Bush and Cheney will do what they can to reinstate the draft. It is the only way that they can continue to feed the “warbeast”, but they don’t dare address this issue before the mid-term elections. At the time that the draft is reinstated only those that can show acceptance to a college, or a physical/mental handicap, will recieve deferments. High school dropouts, especially high in the underpriveldged areas, will become the primary “cannon fodder” for Bush and Co.. Ask Cheney about college deferments, he’s real familiar with them.
So Kerry’s comment wasn’t off base, maybe just a little premature. Now is the time to support Kerry, not the time to tuck tail and roll over to the Republican party and their political pre-election word games.

Posted by VietNamVet | 11/01/06, 08:30 AM EST

Kerry,

Your a smug smug man, but that’s why i voted for you. WHich is to say your not glib, and your smart enought to know the difference. Unfortunately, most of this country was indifferent.
2008 you and Gore!!

I want Smart, Smug men running my country. Not a puppet for the Glib ones.

Posted by Holly | 11/01/06, 08:30 AM EST

I was glad to see Keith Obermann being sensible about this.  John Kerry was not insulting the troops - he was insulting Bush. Now I know that some people equate insulting Bush with insulting the troops, but that wasn’t the case.

As usual the right wing media are doing their best to put on front page news a mispoken joke that Kerry says rather than all the speaking gaffe’s Bush has said over the years and the real terrible things they say such as equating the democrats with the terrorists.  The Republicans don’t have anything to run on so they are trying to find something - anything to use for their talking points. 

Not so sure why they want to bring the Iraq war topic to the front and center right before the election given how unpopular it is.

Meg

Posted by Meg Bergen | 11/01/06, 08:40 AM EST

Matt Stoller at mydd weighs in:

http://www.mydd.com/story/2006/11/1/133150/739

“To those people who are running scared about John Kerry’s misstatement, I have a simple message.  Get some integrity.  John Kerry served in the military and put his life on the line for this country.  He is one of the only sitting Democratic Senators to genuinely oppose this war by taking on his colleague, Senator Lieberman.  He has done a huge amount for candidates this cycle, and will do more in the future.  And yesterday, he misspoke - any one of us could have made that mistake.  The fact that it’s a controversy is actually not John Kerry’s fault, it’s yours.  You bear the responsibility of buying into the fallacy that gaffes like this matter.  You bear the responsibility of equating a slip of the tongue to a war that has killed hundreds of thousands.  ”

Posted by democrafty | 11/01/06, 08:43 AM EST

Suggested text for your next public statement “I support our troops in the best way possible. I’ve fought with them, by them, and for them for my entire adult life. When I see them being mishandled, misled, underfunded, underprotected, and under fire, I speak out and work tirelessly to right these wrongs. My record speaks for itself, and unlike those of some others in high goverment office needs no apology or asterisk.
That said, by my mishandling of a small joke directed at the Bush administration, I may have unintentionally offended others, including some of our brave folks in uniform. To them I sincerely apologize.”
This, or words to this effect, would cut the legs out from under the current Republican glee fest, and we can retake the news cycle…..

Posted by Brad | 11/01/06, 08:47 AM EST

Senator Kerry: Don’t back down. You have nothing to apologize for. Keep firing back. Don’t listen to those Democratic advisors. They led you astray in ‘04. Don’t let them get away with it again.

Posted by Lynne | 11/01/06, 08:48 AM EST

Senator Kerry
Thank you for standing up to thr idiots in the White House
Paul Richard

Posted by Paul Richard | 11/01/06, 08:49 AM EST

I am so upset I can barely type. At all the press for not reporting truthfully about this adminstration, and their hit job on John Kerry.

Combing all speeches, for anything to use as propaganda, the GOP went into full battle mode, overnight, with combined resources I wish they’d apply to fixing this country.

All the GOP know how to do is change the subject and make the issue about anything other than their mistakes. Large ones, that combined military and intelligence agencies have criticized.

Public service is Kerry’s life. You need only look at his legislative record for defending the troops on heath care, their benefits, and trying to end a failed civil war, killing needlessly. 

Read the articulate speeches and see the videos full of passion and smart policy choices about making lives better.

A phrase was omitted, Just ask President Bush, and the word “us.” Two letters vs. $2b and 100 plus lives a month lost in Iraq, far worse than a botched joke. 

As the joke was on Bush, he didn’t feel an apology was due to the man who so failed the troops. Today, on Imus, he felt badly for any misunderstanding by the troops, which wouldn’t have happened, had the GOP not done a hit job.

The dust-up is all about creating political edge, and the manipulation of good people who don’t know the facts. With a GOP willingness to target anyone, taking the spotlight off themselves.

This is also about taking out the most successful fundraiser and hardest worker for the Democrats across the country, no matter the means. He has focused on the importance of 2006 to change the direction of the country.

As in the campaign, the media takes the words out of context, and doesn’t show the full content of Kerry’s response.

I, for one, appreciate how he came back to help, faced errors of the campaign, which, frankly, weren’t the reason for the result. More attacks like these, disenfranchisement of voters by many means, or we could have had the wisdom of a President Kerry.

That loss will always sadden me, but having experienced what we needed locally, Kerry worked tirelessly around the country, building the grassroots and identifying good candidates early. Many without any connection to a presidential contest.

Which brings me to a pre-emption all my own. Don’t let whatever shenanigans the GOP pulls next week be masked by this, their Hail Mary pass, which should fail with any justice. Don’t let this media event be blamed, or mask a potential real story of funny numbers due to voter disenfranchisement, electronic or otherwise. 

We have work to do

Posted by Marjorie G | 11/01/06, 08:50 AM EST

The remarks John Kerry, a respected and honored veteran, made are not demeaning to our countrymen and women who are serving in the armed forces, at home and abroad. Even if Kerry botched a lame joke about the President, he said no more than many of us parents have said to our own teenage children: the more education you receive, the more choices are open to you. The president and many supporters have chosen to try to divert attention from the serious and profound problems they have created by pursuing a war in Iraq by leaping on Kerry’s remarks as an opportunity to once again divide Americans into two black and white camps (the Patriotic and the Unpatriotic). This is a tricky tactic that the many of us with great common sense and sensibility will see through. Talk is cheap. What we wish to see is a thoughtful strategy for extricating us from a dreadful situation that inflammatory demagoguery, sloganeering and mishandled facts got us into in the first place.

Posted by Nanci Hamilton | 11/01/06, 08:50 AM EST

Kerry apologized enough - on Imus.

Here is something useful: http://thepremise.com

There’s an emotional toll to taking on any power structure, let alone a tyrannical one, and I’m feeling that today.  It’s wearying and frustrating and at times disheartening.

But I also know that’s exactly why George Bush and Karl Rove have been walking around with smiles on their faces, bluffing about their invulnerability.  Those men know that the greatest advantage they have is psychological.  They use the bully pulpit — and I do mean bully pulpit — to every advantage in that regard.

Forcing John Kerry to cancel some campaign visits feels like a victory for the Republicans.  I don’t know that it will change one vote, but it feels bad to Democrats and good to Republicans.  That it’s a trumped-up charge being sold to a willing press only feels all the more dispiriting because it’s unfair in the quaint sense of that word.

But making Republican diehards feel momentarily good doesn’t change the voting dynamic in this election year.  Democrats became giddy on their own, not because Republicans had forced them to.  Between ever-increasing margins in polls and ever-increasing projections about a Democratic wave, emotions separated from reality a couple of weeks ago, and that’s what most Democrats are dealing with today.  It’s not that anything real happened, it’s that the emotional backdrop has changed.

Whatever additional mileage the Republicans, the press, and even some Democrats think they can get out of framing John Kerry, I don’t think it’s going to change any votes.  It’s blunting the euphoria that Democrats were feeling, but for my money that’s not necessarily a bad thing.  It’s also lifting the mood of the diehard Republicans, but those people were going to vote Republican anyway.

So where are we?  Election Day is six days away and Iraq is only getting worse.  If the president who sent our troops to die without adequate body armor or a plan for the peace or an exit strategy to bring them home can demonize a political opponent for a slip of the tongue, then that says something about the person he is and the country we live in.  The choice we have is to accept that or try to change it.

I’m trying to change it.  Vote Democrat next Tuesday.

– Mark Barrett

Posted by DiAnne | 11/01/06, 08:52 AM EST

Dear Senator John Kerry,

Considering your military experience, I would like to believe the statement you made about being sent to Iraq was taken out of context. You said it was a botched joke and for that, you should apologize. You are not a comedian. Just stick to the issues and beat them on that. We all make mistakes, but this one doesn’t help the Democratic cause at all. I am not in the military, but I was offended by what was said. Please consider apologizing (for the attempted joke) so we can all get back to the many issues at hand.

Now, because of this mistake I am now banning you from telling anymore jokes. You had your chance and failed. I don’t care where you are. In public, at home, in the car, it doesn’t matter. NO MORE JOKES! Leave them to the real jokesters in office.

Posted by Theo | 11/01/06, 08:55 AM EST

A BOTCHED JOKE IS MEANINGLESS.

A BOTCHED WAR COSTS LIVES.

Ken, that was an amazing post.  Just when you think your outrage is tapped out.  It’s no surprise, given this story, that Bush has felt it necessary to make a mountain out of this particular flyspeck at this moment in time.

Distract!
Attack!

They make me sick.

Posted by Diane | 11/01/06, 08:58 AM EST

“Whatever the intent, Senator Kerry was wrong to say what he said,” said Democratic Rep. Harold Ford Jr., running for Senate in Tennessee.

“Sen. Kerry’s remarks were poorly worded and just plain stupid,” said Montana Senate President Jon Tester, a Democrat trying to unseat GOP Sen. Conrad Burns. “He owes our troops and their families an apology.

Do you not agree with these statements made by members of your own party?

Posted by Meg | 11/01/06, 08:58 AM EST

Kerry has apologized for misspeaking. But he will not (and should not) apologize to Bush for anything. See AP story at the link below:

Kerry Apologizes for ‘A Botched Joke’
By JENNIFER LOVEN
Associated Press Writer

10:12 AM PST, November 1, 2006

WASHINGTON — Sen. John Kerry apologized for “a botched joke” about President Bush’s Iraq policies that led Bush and fellow Republicans to accuse him of insulting U.S. troops. Some Democrats in close races assailed Kerry, while others called the flap a ploy by the GOP to improve its chances in next week’s midterm elections.

“Of course I’m sorry about a botched joke. You think I love botched jokes?” Kerry said during an appearance Wednesday on Don Imus’ nationally syndicated radio program. “I mean, you know, it’s pretty stupid.”

Kerry, D-Mass., said he meant no offense to troops when he told a college audience Monday that young people might get “stuck in Iraq” if they don’t study hard and do their homework.

On Wednesday, he said, “You cannot get into the military today if you do badly in school.” But he also said the White House was purposely twisting his words and asserted that it is Bush who owes troops an apology for a misguided war in Iraq.

“I’m sorry that that’s happened,” he said of his earlier comment. “But I’m not going to stand back from the reality here, which is, they’re trying to change the subject. It’s their campaign of smear and fear.”

Read the rest here: http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/politics/wire/sns-ap-white-house-kerry,1,1565272.story?coll=sns-ap-politics-headlines

Posted by Roxanne | 11/01/06, 08:59 AM EST

Thank You for taking the time to see through the spin machine..this is an important time in Americas history, let’s remember the real issues that are in front of us…..let’s all learn from history….Thanks

Posted by BlueRose | 11/01/06, 09:01 AM EST

This is all a ridiculous ploy by the GOP’s, whom are scared about the real chance that they are going to lose the Congress. They are grasping at straws to try and latch on to anything that would throw some spark of negative press at the democrats. Unfortuantely for Kerry they just happened to turn his misspeak into something. They needed to rally their base, which has been surely dissintegrating. However, The attempt will be futile.

Like the coked up radio host who insulted MJ Fox, I don’t think enough explicatives can describe the way I feel about him. So I’ll satisfy my self with Hypocritical Moron.

Posted by Holly | 11/01/06, 09:04 AM EST

“All blog comments are strictly opinions of the writers and do not reflect the views of Friends of John Kerry.”

“Please be respectful of the opinions of others. Do keep in mind that children will be reading this blog. We reserve the right to edit or remove comments.”

Those two statements completely contradict one another.  By continuously removing content that you disagree with, you are in fact directing and shaping the editorial opinions which are viewable on this blog, as opposed to all of the opinons posted by the readers of this blog, so that they do in fact almost completely “reflect the views of Friends of John Kerry.” 

This is NOT the principles upon which the Democratic Party was founded upon, and I am greatly offended by the actions of the moderators of this blog.
(2)

Posted by Jim Waid | 11/01/06, 09:07 AM EST

to Harold Christensen:

Not all of your information is correct.  Not all soldiers who sign up to go to war or re-enlist get an enlistment bonus.  Remember, many who have been in for several years or return to military service recieve that bonus, even though they are leaving their loved ones or jobs to go to war.  But, maybe you don’t believe that they need that and are just too stupid to care, huh?  After all, my husband did not go to college, but has kept the same job for over 20 years.  But since he did not go to college, he should be stuck with being sent to Iraq, huh?  Even though he finds it an honor to serve his country.

Posted by armywife | 11/01/06, 09:11 AM EST

Mr. Wade:

You have repeatedly (and I mean repeatedly) stated your wish that John Kerry should apologize to the troops. Your point has been made. Not everyone agrees with it. Move on to something else.

JK was not trying to insult the troops, and he apologized for misspeaking. He has no reason to apologize for anything other than that.

Find something else to say, my friend. Your posts are getting tedious.  The mods probably removed them out of sheer boredom.

Posted by KErryOn62 | 11/01/06, 09:12 AM EST

Just sharing with you what I couldn’t resist saying to CNN:

I think that any media outlet or reporter who does their work properly would know that Kerry’s joke was at the end of a string of jokes about George W. Bush being incompetent. If someone would take the time to rewind the tape 30 seconds, we would all see that the joke had nothing to do with the troops. Everyone who cares to do their research knows this - and one would think that CNN reporters would fall under this category. I cannot believe that Kerry’s photograph has been the front story on cnn.com all day long. With an election in less than a week, I am appalled that CNN, the “most trusted news network in America,” is chasing this red herring thrown by the GOP to distract from their long list of failures, the top item being the war in Iraq. My 4 month old puppy is shrewder than you. After pretending to throw the ball for her 3 times, she figures out that it’s just a trick. The GOP has been doing this for years, and you still haven’t figured it out.

Posted by Fado | 11/01/06, 09:15 AM EST

Paula.

Please, oh please. You have no clue of what is really going on. I was in during the first Gulf War. It was for a purpose. It is now for a purpose. You are not military. You do not share the same understanding and commitment we share. You don’t understand how motivated we are to maintain freedom and the purpose of freedom. I want my 3 children to be safe some day so I will support any attempt to stop terrorism!

Yep, that’s me speaking again!

Posted by Another Jarhead | 11/01/06, 09:17 AM EST

VietNamVet, thank you for that post - it was inspiring.  I agree with you that they are just praying for Kerry to apologize so they can crow about how they humbled him.

In my humble opinion he’s handling this exactly the right way by getting out of the other candidates’ spotlights, and using the unexpected media spotlight to democratic advantage.  Make them regret they brought this up.  Especially with today’s Iraq story in the news, this can’t deflect any advantage onto Bush.  People don’t trust him - to say the very least.

Posted by Diane | 11/01/06, 09:18 AM EST

Here’s what Kerry needs to do:

1. Go on Howard Stern.  The shock value from that alone will get people talking.

2. Say that he F***‘d up.  Those exact words.  Say he botched the joke, stuck he foot in his mouth.

3. Say that however, he has no intention of going on bended knee & appologizing to this White House or some of the Right Wing groups calling for his appology.  Make the distinction, & say if the troops need an appology, Kerry will give it.

Just make it clear that he’s not going to appologize to the Right Wing.

Trust me on this, if this comes to pass, Kerry will win big kudos for the Democrat party…

Posted by Kevin | 11/01/06, 09:25 AM EST

Jarhead:

Do you not think the troops deserve a CIC who can find a strategy to win?

What do you say to our own intelligence reports indicating that Iraq is making us less safe and increasing terrorism?  Are they lying?

What do you say to this president’s congress that decreased the VA budget this year by over 800 million dollars?

What do you say to not adequately protecting the troops with upgraded body armor? That was the responsibility of this president’s congress, too, and they didn’t do it. 

We all support the troops. I’d like the administration to support them, too. That’s what JK is talking about. And if you knew anything about his record at all, you’d know that he’s on the side of the troops.

Posted by KerryOn62 | 11/01/06, 09:25 AM EST

Posted by Another Jarhead | November 1, 2006 2:17 PM

Sorry, Jarhead.  But thanks to Rumsfeld and Dubya, this battle is already over.  The Iraqis want us out, and they want to get on with the business of resolving their own issues in whichever fashion they find most appropriate. 

The larger war on terror has been set back at least a generation because of the actions of our Commander-in-Chief and Secretary of Defense.  But if you prefer to believe in the geopolitical equivalent version of Santa Claus, then be my guest.  It’ll not change a thing on the ground.

Posted by Cyrano | 11/01/06, 09:28 AM EST

Reading Harold Ford and Jon Tester’s comments hurt. Considering how hard Kerry has worked, being an early promoter of Tester, a friendship with Ford, and all that financial support.

With the public not knowing the truth, easier to go along with only days remaining, but it’s like the campaign, and the placing of lies that never get corrected.

I read that there was laughter at the event, after a continuing series of jokes, which CBS, and maybe others, chose not include. Showing, dishonestly, that the joke fell flat. The students got it.

Wish some more of the Democrats would call the spin machine out for what it is, even if the candidates feel they can’t.

We need to work in tandem, realize anyone could get swift-boated, to the detriment of the victim, the party, always, unless we fight back.

I, too, am sad, DiAnne, that this crap works.

Posted by Marjorie G | 11/01/06, 09:39 AM EST

And so here we are again, discussing John Kerry’s supposed anti-troop stance when we all know that such a stance is neither accurate nor rational.  Not that accuracy or rationality have been in much supply on the part of Republican politicians or their supporters since this administration took office. 

Time after time we have been subjected to lies, distortions and outrageous mis-characterizions from the conservative spin machines led by none other than the prince of lies himself, the, (hopefully), soon to be late, great Karl Rove.  The only thing is that this time they were handed the distrotion on a silver platter.  I love John Kerry and would vote for him again in a heartbeat but he has to watch what he says.  He is too experienced and savvy a politician to allow this kind of gaf to slip past.

Is anyone suprised that, given the current state of the polls that the right has latched on to this like a rat on roadkill?  They have been sorely in need of something…anything…to hang their swiftboats on and J.K. has given it to them. But in spite of this, they, the republicans, are still in a great deal of difficulty.  John is fighting back this time and there is nothing for the Republicans to gain from this than further discussion of the war in Iraq and that is one thing they want to avoid.  And for good reason.  They have all but failed there.  So, to quote the President, “bring it on”.  We are ready for this attack.  We ought to be, we have been trained to deal with it by the best…the republicans.

I do have to agree with one of the points the president made in response to Mr. Kerry’s remarks.  Our troops are “plenty smart and plenty brave”.  Unfortunately for you Mr. President, more than 2000 are plenty dead as well and that is something we will not forget no matter how much you try and avoid facing up to reality.  nor will we forget that there were no biological weapons, no chemical weapons, no reconstitued nuclear weapons program and all kinds of evidence from the UN inspectors that this was the case prior to the invasion.  that is just the truth Mr. President.  Not a lie, not a distortion, not spin.  The truth.  A thing which you in this late hour before the election, seem determined to avoid.  But we won’t let you, not this time. You can run, but you can’t hide.

Posted by Russ | 11/01/06, 09:40 AM EST

I am a registered independent (former Republican, switched in 1990) who proudly supported and voted for John Kerry in 2004.  I still proudly have my NY’ers for Kerry Edwards bumper sticker on my car, and regularly get comments from disillusioned republicans who say ‘I wish I had…’

I am also a 6 year veteran (peacetime) of the US Marine Corps.

All that having been said, I implore Senator Kerry in the strongest possible terms to not retreat from public appearances, despite what your handlers and political operatives may be saying to you in private, these are the same people who told you not to go on the offensive against the Swift Boat attacks.

It doesnt matter what I know, or what the people who read this blog know, or what any other fair minded people know.  Though someone who read your entire comments is fully aware that you were not denigrating the troops, you have to realize the majority of the people get their ‘news’ from sources like Fox news and the various right wing talking heads.

I urge you to call a press conference, you do owe the troops an apology, but not for your comment.  Though I am not a speechwriter, this is something along the lines of what I would like to hear, and what would take the argument head on and put the republicans back on the defensive.

“I have been hearing a lot of people saying that I owe the troops an apology, and after much consideration I realize that I do owe the troops and the American people an apology, but not for the reasons professed by the various right wing slime machine.

I apologize to the american people, for not fighting harder and winning the presidency in 2004.

Had I won, we would be sitting here discussing the progress we made in stabilizing social security and medicare, instead of wondering how to pay for the republicans misconceived privatization attempts.

Had I won, we would be sitting here discussing the progress we were making on reducing the enormous deficit that the republican administration and congress have run up during their tenure, instead of watching them continue to spend our children into a future of massive government debt.

Had I won, we would be sitting here discussing the real reforms that were taking place with our immigration policy, instead of reading how my republican colleagues have approved a multi billion dollar fence across a small portion of our border, in some misguided effort to appease portions of their base.

Had I won, we would be sitting here discussing how my administration completed implementation of the 9-11 commissions recommendations, instead of continuing to get stonewalled by the current administration, who have failed to implement any.

Had I won, we would be sitting here discussing how under my administration, real changes to our homeland security were taking effect, instead of watching the current administration try to hand control of our ports over to a country that was home to some of the 9-11 hijackers.

Had I won, we could be sitting here talking about the oversight of one government branch to another, instead of finding out after the fact that the sole party in charge chose protecting one of their own over the safety and security of children, entrusted to the care of the page system.

To the troops a special apology; I apologize for not fighting harder to win the presidency.  For not fighting back against the scurrilous attacks against my own military service by those same shadow groups who smeared Senator McCain’s service during the 2000 primary, and for letting a group of people who never served their country in uniform run this government and this brave military.

And mostly, I apologize for not fighting harder to win the presidency, because if I had won, we could be sitting here discussing how the timeline set by my administration in Iraq led to real progress in the transition, and how we were planning to welcome home the last of our brave troops, instead of marking the end of the deadliest month for our brave forces since the invasion.

Our troops deserve better than to serve an administration that would rather spend more american lives than admit they made a mistake.”

Anyway, I have no illusions that anyone in any proximity to the Senator will ever see this, but, on the off chance, please hit back.

Posted by Paul | 11/01/06, 09:40 AM EST

Paul—

I couldn’t agree with you more. And I love the speech, too…

Posted by KerryOn62 | 11/01/06, 09:42 AM EST

Just popping in to say that I’m glad Senator Kerry isn’t rolling over about this.  I’m really heartened that he’s still fighting.  Thanks!

Posted by Cassandra | 11/01/06, 09:47 AM EST

I can see that any comments not fawning all over kerry are not being posted or are being deleted. How fair of you!

Posted by Keri | 11/01/06, 09:52 AM EST

PLEASE - stand your ground, John Kerry.  Don’t apologize, don’t retreat, don’t give an INCH to these lying slandering GOP tools.  They (and the chickenshit coward “Dems” trying to attack you for their own ambitions) are beneath contempt.  You have my full and entire support.  Never retreat, never surrender.

Posted by Rachael | 11/01/06, 09:55 AM EST

Paul:

BEAUTY of a speech. I hope they get it.

Posted by Fe | 11/01/06, 09:55 AM EST

Great post at http://toughenough.org/2006/10/take-two-deep-breaths-and-call-me-in.html:

“Memo to bankrupt republicans: You have so pathetically little of value to show for 6 years in complete control of the U.S. government, that in the last week of the campaign you need to attempt to make the 2006 election a twisted redux of 2004. You can scream as loudly as you want about what word John Kerry left out of a comment he made yesterday, but when all is said and done, you are still out of ideas, out of time, and hopefully soon to be out of office.”

Posted by democrafty | 11/01/06, 09:58 AM EST

A little birdie told me that Kerry is supposed to be on Wolf Blitzer’s show today. Not sure if they mean the 4 PM or the 7 PM version. (all times eastern)

Posted by Roxanne | 11/01/06, 09:59 AM EST

The Democrats are running away from John Kerry as fast as their short little legs can carry them. In the last 12 hours these Democrats have cancelled campaign appearances with Kerry:

- Montana Senate candidate Jon Tester
- Pennsylvania Governor candidate Bob Casy Jr.
- Minnesota Senate candidate Amy Klobuchar
- Minnesota 1st District Congreesman candidate Tim Walz

And Tennesee Senate candidate Harold Ford has called on Kerry to apologize.

This has really angered the Republican base and fired it up, while discouraging the Democrats. It’s a real problem for the Democrats, because the angry left that is the base of the party secretly believes what Kerry said. But they are too cowardly to admit it.

It’s a net plus for the Republicans, and they will continue to throw gasoline on the fire.

Posted by Independent Observation | 11/01/06, 09:59 AM EST

We can’t get a break!!! She is an opportunist just like the Republicans! 

Sen. Clinton visits Kingston, says Kerry should apologize
November 01, 2006

Kingston—Sen. Hillary Clinton, speaking at a Kingston campaign stop this morning, joined the chorus of Democrats criticizing Sen. John Kerry for what the former presidential candidate has called a joke gone awry.

“What Sen. Kerry said was inappropriate,” she said.

Posted by Fleming | 11/01/06, 09:59 AM EST

Give me a break. 
Republicans are such straw-graspers.
I understood exactly what John Kerry meant.  Everyone knows Kerry has the greatest respect and admiration for our troops in Iraq.  The comment was NOT one of disparagement.
The reaction to the comment - taken out of context, mind you- is actually a bona-fide example of the homogenization, hypocrisey and ignorance that IS the republican party in 2006. 

Judi Morgan, Silver Spring, MD

Posted by Judi Morgan | 11/01/06, 09:59 AM EST

Posted by Independent Observation | November 1, 2006 2:59 PM

It has NO impact on the Democratic base; and as for firing up the GOP base…well if they really want more of the same, I guess they just don’t love America.

Posted by Cyrano | 11/01/06, 10:03 AM EST

I am not an extreme leftist by any means, but I am a Democrat through and through. I don’t march for causes that I find meanial and I don’t promote politicians that I don’t believe in. I do, however, believe in John Kerry. Maybe his comments sounded cruel, but we are fighting a cruel war in Iraq right now. I am afraid that we are heading for another Vietnam. And with Sen. Kerry being a vet from that horrific war, maybe he feels the same way. I say keep up the good work Senator. Freedom of Speech is still alive and kicking the the good ole U.S.A.

Posted by Lisa | 11/01/06, 10:04 AM EST

JOHN KERRY -

READ MY LIPS:

PLEASE get on EVERY SINGLE SHOW that will have you.  PLEASE do a full media tour.  PLEASE convince the people in America that a DEMOCRATIC congress is for the best.  This is the only way you can come out on top.  PLEASE John Kerry!  Please read this!  Get on TV!  Get on the Radio!  GET THE MESSAGE OUT.  You are in high demand.  Make use of it!

GET OUT THERE KERRY!!!  FOR THE GOOD OF THE COUNTRY!!!

Posted by Chris F. | 11/01/06, 10:07 AM EST

Senator Kerry needs better writers, or he should cease his lame attempts at humor.

“President Bush used to live in the state of Texas.  Now he lives in the a state of denial.” 

That is supposed to be perceived as wit?  It reminds me of a third grader telling an ancient joke he or she just heard as if it were new.  So proud of his comedic talent, yet unaware of his lack of originality.

I accept that Senator Kerry left the word “us” out of his “joke” and meant to demean President Bush, not the troops.

If President Bush attempted to tell a poorly conceived joke, and forgot to include a word, resulting in a perceived gaffe, Democrats would deride him as an idiot.

Senator Kerry blows a pre-conceived, obviously reheased,  witless joke and in his, and other Democrats’ eyes, he’s a victim.

Dick Cheney is a poor marksman, he made a mistake and shot his hunting buddy.

John Kerry is a poor comedian, he made a mistake and fatally wounded his 2008 Presidential campaign.

Posted by Len | 11/01/06, 10:11 AM EST

FROM STEVE GILLIARD:

Calm the **** down

Yeah, let’s talk about Iraq

Jesus, so many people are so nervous about what John Kerry said, like he’s lying.

John Kerry is telling the truth and everyone knows it. Rich kids do not join the military, college bound kids don’t join the military, only the poor and those who can’t get scholarships do. Acting like he was lying or insulting people is just bull.

Besides, his reply got far more play than the original statement.

“If anyone thinks a veteran would criticize the more than 140,000 heroes serving in Iraq and not the president who got us stuck there, they’re crazy. This is the classic G.O.P. playbook. I’m sick and tired of these despicable Republican attacks that always seem to come from those who never can be found to serve in war, but love to attack those who did.

I’m not going to be lectured by a stuffed suit White House mouthpiece standing behind a podium, or doughy Rush Limbaugh, who no doubt today will take a break from belittling Michael J. Fox’s Parkinson’s disease to start lying about me just as they have lied about Iraq. It disgusts me that these Republican hacks, who have never worn the uniform of our country lie and distort so blatantly and carelessly about those who have.

The people who owe our troops an apology are George W. Bush and Dick Cheney who misled America into war and have given us a Katrina foreign policy that has betrayed our ideals, killed and maimed our soldiers, and widened the terrorist threat instead of defeating it. These Republicans are afraid to debate veterans who live and breathe the concerns of our troops, not the empty slogans of an Administration that sent our brave troops to war without body armor.

Bottom line, these Republicans want to debate straw men because they’re afraid to debate real men. And this time it won’t work because we’re going to stay in their face with the truth and deny them even a sliver of light for their distortions. No Democrat will be bullied by an administration that has a cut and run policy in Afghanistan and a stand still and lose strategy in Iraq .”

This is supposed to hurt Dems?

They’re lucky he didn’t ask why NO member of the Bush family has enlisted to serve in the military. They want to extend this discussion another day, fine by me. Because I have a boatload to add about who serves and who doesn’t.

I saw Arianna’s latest handwringing as well.

Stop it.

The GOP is pulling back from more districts every day. They are on the run. George Allen and Marilyn Musgrave have staffers assaulting people on camera. John Kerry got a golden opportunity to call Bush and the GOP cowards on Iraq. And by extending the conversation on Iraq, on a day when US forces were forced to abandon the search for a US soldier on Iraqi government orders is a day I want to talk about Iraq.

People are getting nervous, fearing every mistake might turn the tide for the GOP.

MARK FOLEY HIT ON KIDS IN CONGRESS.

It’s really just that simple. They can’t fix that, they can’t change that. And it sets the stage for a discussion on Iraq, how they can’t do anything right.

There isn’t a day which doesn’t have another Republican accused of a crime, not bribery but attempted rape, today.

Iraq is the topic of the day, and every time Bush talks about” staying until the job is done”. No one knows what the **** he’s talking about. What job? When does it end? Now, people are worried that the GOP says Kerry thinks soldiers are stupid.

Please, that’s what conservatives like Andrew Sullivan have said outright. That’s how Rumsfeld acts.

Posted by Ken | 11/01/06, 10:12 AM EST

It’s a net plus for the Republicans, and they will continue to throw gasoline on the fire.

Posted by Independent Observation | November 1, 2006 2:59 PM
===========================

NOTHING could be a net plus for the Republicans at this point of their death spiral.

Reality: I hope this sticks around for days, so that JK can continue to bash the sh** out of those chicken hawks.  Can’t wait. 

Meanwhile, back at the HackCave, Karl Rove is trying to figure out a way to shift Kerry’s comments to mean that we’re winning in Iraq…

Old Karl really stepped in it this time.

Nice try “Independent Observer”

Posted by KerryOn62 | 11/01/06, 10:14 AM EST

Reading Harold Ford and Jon Tester’s comments hurt. Considering how hard Kerry has worked, being an early promoter of Tester, a friendship with Ford, and all that financial support.

With the public not knowing the truth, easier to go along with only days remaining, but it’s like the campaign, and the placing of lies that never get corrected.

I read that there was laughter at the event, after a continuing series of jokes, which CBS, and maybe others, chose not include. Showing, dishonestly, that the joke fell flat. The students got it.

Wish some more of the Democrats would call the spin machine out for what it is, even if the candidates feel they can’t.

We need to work in tandem, realize anyone could get swift-boated, to the detriment of the victim, the party, always, unless we fight back.

The repeating of the same rote talking points have lost their initial sting. I am just sad about the wasted attention to the wrong thing, when Kerry has spoken truth about the Iraq occupation and failed Bush presidency.

Let’s work extra hard, knowing their machine is always cranked up, and we just got a glimpse. Our mission is too important to become lost.

Posted by Marjorie G | 11/01/06, 10:15 AM EST

Posted by Paul | November 1, 2006 2:40 PM

Absolutely Paul. That is what America needs to hear.

Posted by oncall | 11/01/06, 10:17 AM EST

what’s wrong with what JK said? he later clarified that he meant the Pres., not the troops. we all know it’s harder to go to college than to fight a war halfway across the world. I mean, calculus? puh-lease! give me the M-16 and let me be.

Posted by IrishMan | 11/01/06, 10:21 AM EST

It is interesting to see all who beat up Bush.  John Kerry makes a botched joke and it is Bush’s fault.  Kerry- stand up and apologize to the troops.  If you cannot see that you are not perfect, examine closer.  What you said offended the people defending us.  What you said is what came out.  Apologize to the men taking care of us.  If you did not mean to, apologize.  Simple Kindergarten principle.  Let’s not blame the Republicans for your miscommunication.

Posted by Dustin | 11/01/06, 10:31 AM EST

Why am I not surprised about Hillary.

Posted by Marjorie G | 11/01/06, 10:31 AM EST

Ken, while it is true that the military targets the economic underclass, it is in no way what Kerry meant.

I have two middle-class cousins, both very well educated and intelligent, who volunteered for the military.

Also, Kerry was a college graduate who came from a comfortable background and he still volunteered for a war that he wasn’t so sure about.

So please don’t generalize the type of person who would join the military or assume that what Kerry mistakendly said is true.

It’s not, and Kerry knows it. He’s one of the educated who went off and got stuck in a quagmire. He never, ever, meant to say those terrible, untrue words as part of a botched joke about an uneducated president.

Posted by Brett | 11/01/06, 10:32 AM EST

Marjorie,

“Reading Harold Ford and Jon Tester’s comments hurt” and regarding other Democrats who criticize Kerry for short term political expediency:

We know that sooner or later the Republican Noise Machine will create their own lies to attack the other Democrats. They will learn that a right wing lie should never be given any credibility.

It is also a safe bet that, when they inevitably come under attack, John Kerry will be one of the first to stand up and defend them.

Posted by Ron Chusid | 11/01/06, 10:35 AM EST

Wow. The death toll of US troops in Iraq is 105 for the month of October, 2006. That’s an increasing trend, not a decrease. Iraq is in civil war and our troops are taking orders from a foreign leader.  (Imagine the uproar if the CIC was named Clinton….)

It’s amazing how many people are falling for the Bushies attempt at distracting from what is really going on. But I suspect that in the end, the Bushies will find out most Americans are smarter than the wingers give them credit for.

Posted by MH | 11/01/06, 10:35 AM EST

I was not going to weigh in on this, but, I feel I must. I realize that you are intending on running in ‘08 again Mr. Kerry, but, now that we have the GOP on the run, we do not need this election to be all about YOU personally.

The GOP is very good at latching on to this sort of “miss step”. When we have incidents like this, Things like Mark Foley get pushed out of the forefront.

Your decision to be continually on the defensive cost us the White House in 2004; Please do not allow your over-aggressive intentions to gain the White House in 2008 cause harm to the candidates in 2006 by being over aggressive.

I supported you in 2004, and unfortunately we lost. I would like to win in 2006. I do not blame you entirely, as I understand what you truly meant to say, but, here we are with less than one week to go, and we are now re-hashing your defeat all over the news media. PLEASE stop Mr. Kerry, there are far too many close elections for us to rebound from any more of your unintentional “miss-steps”.

Michael Pratt

Posted by Michael | 11/01/06, 10:38 AM EST

You neocons know what Kerry meant.  He was talking about the President and his failed policies.

Posted by Jane Hamsher | 11/01/06, 10:38 AM EST

Thanks, Jane. Nice to have you here.

Posted by karen | 11/01/06, 10:40 AM EST

I am the mother of a 2nd Lt who flies out today to be stationed in Baghdad for 18 months.  He was an honor student in college, commander of his ROTC unit, is a Ranger and has chosen to serve his country. He did not end up in the military because he isn’t smart or is lazy.
However the politicians want to spin things to fling mud at each other fine, but do not insinuate that those who serve are somehow lacking in skills to do anything else.
If you mis-speak, correct it. Say what you mean. If John Kerry doesn’t feel he should apologize, perhaps he needs to say what he feels about those who serve in our military.
I don’t care if he has praised them a thousand times. Say it again.
They preserve your right to speak your mind, so get your words straight!

Posted by Tonya L | 11/01/06, 10:42 AM EST

That is not what was said.  I am not asking for any apologies except for the troops.  In the realm of politics, it is a different story.  When a normal person says something wrong, they apologise.

Nothing conservative and liberal… just plain common courtesy.

Posted by Dustin | 11/01/06, 10:42 AM EST

Many of us have been living in a dream word, that if the Dems get in everything will be fine. Bush and Chaney are dispicable cowards, but the hapless Dems are not far behind when it comes to courage. I am ashamed of being a suporter of Democrats. They run scared at the drop of a hat and must bear some responsibility for the necon take over. They cannot even muster the strength to take on the Republicans by defending Senator Kerry.

I haven’t been able to verify yet if Tenent and Ford are swiftboating Senator Kerry today, but if it is true, payback will be hard a swift for these cowards.

As a former combat officer with the 101st in Northern I Corps and purple heart recipient, I am livid with these yellow scumbag democrats as I am furious with the media and Bush.

Posted by peterbaldwin | 11/01/06, 10:48 AM EST

Michael,

It is not a case of Kerry making missteps. Every candidate who is out there as much as John Kerry is will inevitably have some gaffes. There are whole books of Bush gaffes.

In the internet (or internets for those who found this on the googles) era every minor misstatement will be reported and video will be place on line.

No matter which Repubican runs, the right wing noise machine will find ways to create such controversies as they try to avoid the real issues until the public finally gets fed up. Put in a different candidate and we will have the same problems.

What is significant is that John Kerry is showing he is able to stand up to these lies.

Posted by Ron Chusid | 11/01/06, 10:52 AM EST

Another great post by Taylor Marsh:

http://www.taylormarsh.com/archives_view.php?id=24766

Posted by democrafty | 11/01/06, 10:53 AM EST

Jane Hamsher,

“You neocons know what Kerry meant. He was talking about the President and his failed policies.”

No, you are wrong.  :)

Not all of them know this. They are sheep who listen to the right wing noise machine and believe what they hear.

They really think Kerry insulted the troops when we both know he did no such thing.

The concept of fact checking means nothing to them.

After all, if there weren’t so many people who believe the lies of the right wing noise machine, Bush would never have been reelected (or gotten into office in the first place).

Posted by Ron Chusid | 11/01/06, 10:54 AM EST

Sir,
  Good afternoon Sir, I recently saw a news cast on the comment you made saying that the reason why our service members are in Iraq is because, they can’t hack it in college. As a veteran and a current college student who has honorably served my country, I am shocked and in awe on such a disrespectful comment.  I can’t see how this was meant to humorous. Maybe it would be humorous to the insurgents in Iraq, but not to the mother of the Fallen 18 year old Marine who gave his life defending ours.  Sir your comment lacked taste, leadership, and most importantly the respect and compassion for those who have given the ultimate sacrifice to our nation, our military service members, and veterans.  I just can’t get over that fact, that this tasteless comment is coming from a decorated combat veteran who served his country and knows the significance and sacrifice it takes to wear the U.S. military uniform.  Sir I currently have and have lost friends in combat, and I don’t want to believe that their commitment and sacrifice to our nation was not because they couldn’t get into a respectable college, but because of loyalty, patronage, and unselfishness to our great nation.  Even though I am not a resident of Ma, and my opinion may not count I feel that I have the obligation as a veteran and a citizen to speak in behalf of those who cannot speak in their defense.  I joined the military not because I couldn’t get in to college but because I believe in our great nation, in democracy, freedom, and most of all to secure the freedom of my in this great country.  George W. Bush may not be making the best decisions, but he is human as we all are, of one thing I am certain is that our President the Commander in Chief would never belittle his troops and defenders of our nation.  Sir, I hope that you plan to apologize about your comments, and not use the G.O.P as a scapegoat who you claim are blowing your “joke” out of proportion.  Sir I must remind you that as a Naval Officer, Senator, and American you have a duty to apologize to the men and women in Uniform, what you said was wrong and as a result you have insulted the service members that come from your state, your political party, and most importantly lowered the morale of those in the battle field.

Posted by THE MARINES, MARINE | 11/01/06, 10:58 AM EST

If I forget John Kerry’s remarks about our troops in the past, that he was talking to his base, that is GPA was lower than Bush’s, that his IQ is lower than Bush’s, and I stop thinking, I might believe him that hemade a botched joke.

That being said, I haven’t heard his apology to the troops.  If he did indeed make a botched joke, what is so hard about saying “I mispoke, and I apologize to any troops that are offended?”

Posted by mghirsch | 11/01/06, 11:00 AM EST

It’s not about Kerry.  It’s about the Republicans attacking the messenger instead of the person who attacks the troops through his own neglegence and the neglegence of his own administration and party.

This is a 24 hour story, but the bigger story is ready to burst out there.

Posted by Captain Sparrow | 11/01/06, 11:02 AM EST

Jane:

Nice post “PR101” at http://www.firedoglake.com!!

Posted by Fe | 11/01/06, 11:02 AM EST

As usual the Republican propaganda machine chooses to shoot the messenger and ignore the message. They choose to insult Sen. Kerry and twist the meaning of his words. Americans are not that ignorant. They know what he meant. What is truly insulting is that it has become so expensive to get a college education that many young people feel that the only way to get one is to join the military for a ” promised ” tuition. Too bad many of them will die before they can take advantage of that promise. Also, where were these ” defenders of the troops ”  in March of 2004 when the President was making a joke about finding WMD’s while looking all around his office and under the furniture ? Now that was truly in bad taste. But they thought it was funny. Maybe George is just a better comedian, or maybe the jokes on us.

Posted by Thomas | 11/01/06, 11:04 AM EST

It does seem to me, after seeing the sheer number of posts on the last threads that are critical of John Kerry, that it would not have mattered WHAT he did or said this last week; anything was likely to be misconstrued.

I think this speaks to the desperation of the right, as well as the amount of time they seem to have to post vitriol on a website.

As for the so-called Dems who are coming here over and over, please help out with the voters in your district.  Seriously, we all have a lot of work to do and you can help.  GOTV; worry about JK later.

Posted by karen | 11/01/06, 11:05 AM EST

Kathy,
Please work hard to gotv in your district. That will help more than anything else.

Posted by karen | 11/01/06, 11:09 AM EST

That being said, I haven’t heard his apology to the troops. If he did indeed make a botched joke, what is so hard about saying “I mispoke, and I apologize to any troops that are offended?”

Posted by mghirsch | November 1, 2006 4:00 PM

Mr. Hirsch:

The apology was already made by Senator Kerry this morning.

The bigger apology HAS TO COME from the President who led our people into getting killed - over 2800 of them to be exact—in the three years of this “Mission Accomplished” war in Iraq.

As a matter of fact, an apology from the President isn’t enough. He needs to be tried in the World Court as a war criminal, and in the US for dereliction of duty in subverting the writ of habeus corpus—a basic tenet of the Constitution he swore on a stack of bibles to uphold when he was inaugurated—-twice.

Posted by Nik | 11/01/06, 11:09 AM EST

Posted by THE MARINES, MARINE | November 1, 2006 3:57 PM

That’s not what kerry said, nor is it what he was even talking about.  Time to change the channel and get the whole story before you upset yourself again.

You should look at the transript of the whole text of Kerry’s remarks at Pasadena.  You might notice that it doesn’t mention the troops ONCE.  NOT ONCE.

Then come back and we’ll talk.

Posted by casey | 11/01/06, 11:11 AM EST

Statement of Senator John Kerry

As a combat veteran, I want to make it clear to anyone in uniform and to their loved ones: my poorly stated joke at a rally was not about, and never intended to refer to any troop.

I sincerely regret that my words were misinterpreted to wrongly imply anything negative about those in uniform, and I personally apologize to any service member, family member, or American who was offended.

It is clear the Republican Party would rather talk about anything but their failed security policy. I don’t want my verbal slip to be a diversion from the real issues. I will continue to fight for a change of course to provide real security for our country, and a winning strategy for our troops.

###

Posted by karendc | 11/01/06, 11:11 AM EST

Dear Grunt,
I appreciate you being there fighting for us. But I think you should re-examine Kerry’s comments.  First, he was there in the thick of things(Veitnam).  G.W. went to college and when he was done with that, did he join the military to fight in Nam?  The Texas Air National Guard was a nice safe place for him.  And he didn’t even attend that on a regular basis.  I understand Kerry’s comment first hand.  During a conflict like this, parents put their kids in college to keep them from harms way.  Kids go to college in these time, as I did during Veitnam, for the same reason.  I didn’t believe in that war and I don’t believe in this one because I believe it was Premeditated!

As far as an appology from Kerry and/or the rest of the Democratic Party, go back and reread VeitNam Vet’s response.  It’s everything John Kerry himself should have shot back at the GOP.  ‘Nam Vet was dead on that this is another “Swiftboat” and the DNP needs to stand up the the bullies of the GOP.

Posted by Bristol Phil | 11/01/06, 11:13 AM EST

Any moderately intelligent person who read Kerry’s original remarks about getting stuck in Iraq would know he was talking about Bush and not our troops, but Kerry should know better than anyone the Republicans are waiting for any opportunity to distort the truth. That’s why Kerry and other Democrats have to be very careful about what they say.

At this point it might be best to skip the jokes and focus exclusively on the issues. The facts speak for themselvs and must be repeated over and over until they can no longer be denied:

- We strongly support all of our troops but not the policy that put them in Iraq.
- We must change our failed policy in Iraq to keep America safe.
- President Bush is the greatest misleader in the history of our nation.

Posted by Troy | 11/01/06, 11:22 AM EST

Posted by Dustin | November 1, 2006 3:30 PM

Okay, well if that is your point of view, can I see the posts and letter to the White House demanding that the Bush, Cheney, Rice, Rumsfailed, Feith, and the rest of them apologize for lying, um, I mean miscommunicating the intelligence on the war to Iraq?

There must be THOUSANDS from you to Bush alone, demanding apologies for a whole host of things, like saying OBGYNS should practice their love on women all over the country, of using the troops as a Thanksgiving prop along with the fake turkey….let’s have them.  I am sure they will make for fascinating reading.

Let’ be clear here:  If you think Kerry should apologize for botching a joke, but Bush gets a pass on botching a war, you have your priorities ass backwards.

Let us remember what blaming troops really looks like: Remember that when they said the insurgency was a result, not of their piss poor planning, but the “spectacular success” of our troops, in other words, because the troops did well, they caused Iraq to be a failure…remember THAT?).  Or how about the multi billion dollar deficit in the VA budget that they knew about but Nicholson (sec. Vet affairs) lied about to Congress?  Or how about no body armor?  Or how about Halliburton KNOWING supplying the troops with contaminated water and the Pentagon giving them MORE contracts and no criminal charges?

Wake up, Dustin.  The real people who should be apologizing aren’t here—they are in a big White House on Pennsylvania Avenue.

Posted by casey | 11/01/06, 11:25 AM EST

No matter how you spin it - Kerry stumbled again.

The second critical article today on Kerry becoming a campaign pariah on the Democratic Party frontier:

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20061101/ap_on_el_ge/election_rdp

Not good for future aspirations when your party peers step aside.

Next…

Posted by CSE | 11/01/06, 11:25 AM EST

Michael Pratt,

Although I respect your right to your opinion, my opinion differs from yours in that I felt that John Kerry was not on the defensive during the ‘04 election.  I strongly felt that he tried as hard as he could to not sling mud, and to be a gentleman throughout the campaign.

I am thankful and proud of John Kerry for standing up to the President and Cheney and Rumsfeld these last two days by saying that they are the ones who owe America an apology for falsely leading this nation to war and being responsible for killing thousands of our nation’s best young women and men, along with tens of thousands of innocent civilians.

Thank you, Senator Kerry!!!!

If they insist on an apology, apologize for a bad joke, then let them have it with your left hook!!!!

Posted by sherrynd | 11/01/06, 11:26 AM EST

NIK

I watched Kerry this morning.  He did not apologize to the troops.  He bloviated and talked around his statement of yesterday, but there was no apology, clear or otherwise.

Posted by mghirsch | 11/01/06, 11:28 AM EST
Posted by democrafty | 11/01/06, 11:29 AM EST

Kerry should not apologize for his statement.
It’s the truth, and the truth hurt’s. Learn from it and grow.

Posted by cireny | 11/01/06, 11:29 AM EST