Marking the 4th Anniversary of the Invasion of Iraq

JK responded after the President’s speech concerning the fourth anniversary of the invasion of Iraq:

“Patience is not a strategy. As we enter the fifth year of war in Iraq with American soldiers policing a civil war between Iraqis, it is clear we need a new policy and change must come from Congress,” said Kerry. “Nearly every prediction this Administration has made about Iraq has been wrong. Wrong about the costs, wrong about how long it would take, wrong about the strain it would place on our military. Now the Administration is wrong to ignore our generals who tell us that there is no military solution to the civil war in Iraq. Unless this Administration is willing to accept more and more years of war in Iraq with no end in sight, we need a regional, diplomatic strategy for peace and a deadline for redeployment to pressure Iraqis to solve their differences.”

It’s hard to believe that we are entering our 5th year in Iraq. BarbinMD wrote a diary today entitled “4 Years” that really hit home with me. It made JK’s point in a very poignant manner. It is not possible to excerpt it meaningfully. Please read for yourself. <!-more->   And last we have a selection from JK blogging community member Joseph Rampulla. Joe painted this the day after the invasion started.

 

portrait3-20-2003-350x461.jpg

Artist: Joseph Rampulla

 


14 Comments

New comments for this entry are closed.

Very sobering post. In keeping with BarbinMD’s diary at Daily Kos, two quotes:

“The new strategy will need more time to take effect. And there will be good days and there will be bad days ahead as the security plan unfolds. —George Bush

Much Of Iraq Is ‘Stable,’ There’s Just ‘One Bombing A Day That Discourages Everybody’.—Laura Bush

Iraq is a tragedy. On my good and bad days I lament the actions and words of Bush, his wife and his cronies.

Posted by ProSense | 03/19/07, 04:39 PM EST

Wow.  What an incredibly haunting painting Joe, especially considering all that has happened during the past four years.  One can only imagine how much more sorrow would be etched on the face of the woman now.  Thank you for sharing this with the JK community.

Posted by Island Blue | 03/19/07, 04:46 PM EST

BarbinMD’s diary is a sad, succinct chronology of the Decider-in-Chief’s willful, deliberate denial of reality. And Joe’s painting all too aptly sums up the way we all felt on that day, and continue to feel. We can only hope and pray that the increasing pressure on the White House coming from a thoroughly disillusioned citizenry and the leadership of a growing number of public servants like Senator Kerry can bring this disastrous misadventure to an end before we’re back here marking its fifth anniversary as well.

Posted by Otter | 03/19/07, 04:52 PM EST

This picture perfectly goes with a story from an Iraqi student that appeared in the Washington Post today. Ayub Nuri wrote about his hopes for the outcome of the war and how those hopes have faded away. Mr. Nuri started out talking about a trip he took around Iraq shortly after the start of the war and the hopeful people that he met then.

Three-and-a-half years later, I took the same trip I took at the start of the war.

I found the people who danced in the streets of Kirkuk disappointed and skeptical about the future of their city. Near Hussein’s hometown, angry people had kept their vows and become insurgents. In Baghdad, the streets were as lifeless as they were those first days. In Hilla, the smiles disappeared as car bombs created new mass graves.


The war has united Iraqis in their disappointment. I ask myself if our expectations were too high. It is hard to answer. But I look back and realize that the fears that I had four years ago were misplaced: If Bush had changed his mind about the war, things might be better now.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/03/18/AR2007031801057.html

 

Posted by taytay | 03/19/07, 05:01 PM EST

Light a candle for peace.

http://www.webshots.com/sp/peace_candle/

Posted by fedup | 03/19/07, 05:26 PM EST

Today on the 4th annual rememberance of our attack on Iraq, I’m saddened even more as I remember my part in this matter.  Because I was one who believed GWB and his administration when they said there were WMD.  I believed them when they said it would be done in 2 months.  I believed them when they said it would be a good thing to topple Saddaam.

I feel like we’re living in some Greek tragedy except it’s real life! 
Maybe you remember those 7 deadly sins and the Cardinal Virtues (as taught in Greek Philosophy and the early church).

This war on Iraq seems to encompass the deadliest of those sins: lies, greed, glutteny, etc..  I feel sickened knowing that innocent lives are lost because our leaders behaved like prophets but were instead false ones.

So as Bush and Cheney and Republicans shout doomsday over the future fall of Iraq, I wonder why anyone would believe them.  They’ve already led Iraq into Hell and they are taking the world with them. 

Senator Kerry, you offer some hope that we can attempt to stop the destruction that’s going on.  You and the 48 other people who signed on with your bill are not leading us to destruction, instead you are putting a stay on the destructive course they’ve set upon us and you are making it possible to turn things around and improve the situation.

So please, keep fighting to bring the troops home alive.

Posted by Tia | 03/19/07, 05:27 PM EST

I was troubled by the e-mail below.

Your word choice (or your staffer’s word choice)includes language inferring what is happening in the Beltway is akin to war.

I spent six weeks in ‘04 in Reno NV trying to get W out of office.

I’ve been to Baghdad in ‘03 and I’ve seen what war is about and I think you can do better in your verbiage.

-Jess Sullivan


—- John Kerry wrote:

>
>
> Hi Jess,
>
> Here on the fourth anniversary of the beginning of
> the Iraq War, I just wanted to drop a quick note to
> all of you, updating you on the state of progress in
> the Iraq debate and legislation in the Senate.
>
> Last week, I voted for legislation I brought to the
> floor with Sen. Harry Reid, Sen. Biden and Sen.
> Levin, legislation that demands, once again, that we
> change course and set a deadline for the
> redeployment of our troops in Iraq.
>
> You were there at the start, so I don’t need to
> remind you that when Russ Feingold and I first
> introduced legislation to do exactly that, there
> were 13 of us in the Senate that voted for it. Now,
> in no small part because of all of your work pushing
> for change, nearly the entire Democratic caucus
> stood together in this important vote—48
> Democrats strong.
>
> I just wanted to thank you, all of you, for getting
> us this far. Your help (and courage because I know
> it isn’t always easy to speak out) has shifted the
> debate a long way. We still have more fighting to
> do, of course; the legislation came up just short of
> passing. I’m an impatient person, but I’ve been in
> the Senate long enough to know that these things
> take time. That’s the nature of legislating. And we
> can’t stop until we finish this fight. I learned a
> long time ago that you support the troops by getting
> the policy right, and that’s the only endgame here
>—but progress is progress, and I want you to know
> and see what you’ve accomplished.
>
> I’ll let you know some of the ways you can help. But
> that’s later; for now, I just wanted to send off
> this email to thank you for getting us this far.
> Together, we can do this.
>
> John Kerry
>
> P.S. I saw this article a while ago ... I hope it’s
> as big a reminder for you as it is for me of why we
> must get this job done:
>
> Soldier’s Death Strengthens Senators’ Antiwar
> Resolve
>
>
> -
> |Paid for by John Kerry for Senate |
> -

Posted by jess | 03/19/07, 05:52 PM EST

Hi Jess:

First of all, thank you for your service.

Second, I was a little confused by what you found troubling in the e-mail.  (I didn’t see it.)  I don’t think people should throw terms around that imply that anything is like war, war is something that seems to be comparable only to itself.  But, in all honesty, I didn’t get the reference.  Help?

thanks!

Posted by taytay | 03/19/07, 06:00 PM EST

jess,

I received the same email today and I didn’t get the same inference from it that you did about it using war metaphors. Re-reading it again in your comment, I still don’t see any implications that what Kerry’s doing in Washington is supposed to be akin to war.

I do see where he uses the phrase “we still have more fighting to do” but that’s clearly in reference to Kerry and his supporters having to continue their fight to get the legislation passed in the Senate. I also see the word “endgame” in there, but that’s a gaming metaphor rather than a military one (it’s derived from classical chess strategies).

So unless you’re taking the idea of “we can’t stop until we finish this fight” as a metaphor for military combat in Iraq—which doesn’t seem intuitive to me at all, and I expect that it wouldn’t to Kerry’s staff or to most other recipients of the email—then I’m afraid you’ve lost me on this one. Care to explain your reasoning a little more so that I can understand where you’re coming from?

Oh, and for what it’s worth—I was greatly (and gratefully) surprised when I read this email on my computer this morning to actually get a communication from a political figure that actually did not beg for money at the end. It was unexpected but certainly welcome, and it made me feel a lot better about being a supporter of Kerry’s legislative initiatives and not just an online ATM machine for his campaign committee.

Posted by Otter | 03/19/07, 06:09 PM EST

A Letter to Senator Kerry on the fourth anniversary of the Iraq war

Dear Senator Kerry,

Thirty-six years ago, at age 27, you testified to the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, on behalf of veterans protesting the continuation of the Vietnam War.  You astounded the Committee with your grasp of the problems facing America in trying to disengage from that war, prompting President Nixon to put you immediately on his Enemies List.

Some of the general points you made in your 1971 testimony: 

        “To attempt to justify the loss of one American life. . .by linking such loss to the preservation of freedom. . .is the height of criminal hypocrisy.”

        “Each day, to facilitate the process by which the United States washes her hands of Vietnam, someone has to give up his life, so that the United States doesn’t have to admit something that the entire world already knows. . .we have made a mistake.”

        “We are asking here in Washington for some action from the Congress of the United States of America, which has the power to raise and maintain armies, and which by the Constitution also has the power to declare war.”

        “I do not believe that this Congress will, in fact, end the war as we would like to, which is immediately and unilaterally. . .[But] I would say we should set a date that is the earliest possible. . .I do not believe it is necessary to stall any longer.”

Chairman Fulbright commented on your eloquence and its enormous benefit to the country, and Senator Pell said, “I hope, before Mr. Kerry’s life ends, he will be a colleague of ours in this body.”

And so you are today—a member of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, as the country is mired in another civil war on foreign soil.  Appropriately, you are one of the Senators leading the charge for setting a deadline of a year for full withdrawal from Iraq.  But, just as with Vietnam, we Americans also need to learn from our tragic mistakes and hold our politicians responsible.  We badly need another Fulbright committee investigation of this war and this administration.  Can you push this through for us?

Tela Zasloff, Williamstown, MA

——
Author of “A Rescuer’s Story: Pastor Pierre Charles Toureille in Vichy France” (The University of Wisconsin Press, 2003) and “Saigon Dreaming, Recollections of Indochina days” (St. Martin’s Press, 1990).

Posted by Tela Zasloff | 03/20/07, 05:04 AM EST

That picture has definitely made me pause.  Joe, if you’re reading, thank you for painting this to show the mood that really represents what a grave thing it is to start a war just because you can.

Posted by beachmom | 03/20/07, 11:49 AM EST

Joe Rampulla’s painting also expresses my dispair in the way our country has been played by the Bush administration.
Fueled by misinformation, and fanned with a twisted notion
of patriotism; the way educated dissenting opinion has been
consistently sneered at.
So much of personal freedom and privacy is now threatened;
not from the mid-east but from within.

Posted by Steven R Martin | 03/21/07, 03:23 AM EST

Why no mention in the speech last night of Ngo Dinh Diem or Archibald Cox?

Posted by Shimmy | 03/21/07, 06:02 AM EST

I am hoping someone can answer this question for me. Are there any plans to reintroduce the Iraq war withdrawal plan again for another vote in the near future? If so, how will it be reintroduced, can it be introduced as part of a war supplemental?

Posted by Probus | 03/21/07, 01:31 PM EST