Moving the Goalposts Again
That moving of the goalposts that the Senator talked about is ongoing. The Administration wants to make the tactics the goal. The escalation, according to this argument, is working because there are military successes. However, that was not the reason giving for adding more American troops to the conflict.
Sen. Kerry, in the ABC News interview this morning, talked about the actual reasons that the Congress was given to justify putting more troops in harms way;
to give the Iraqi government time to work out the oil sharing revenue law,
to plan provincial elections,
to develop a general amnesty plan, and
deal with the de-Baathification law and its consequences.
There has been no progress in these areas. The GAO Report released last week noted this, the American Security Project report released last Wednesday noted this and the Iraq Security Fores Independent Assessment Commission, headed by Retired Gen. James L. Jones noted this. The escalation has not delivered on its stated goals. It has failed.
The New York Times lead editorial in it’s Sunday edition strongly condemns the Bush Administration for trying to hide behind Gen Patraeus. The goal of the escalation was not to compile American military victories. It was to give the Iraqis time to solve their political differences and begin a national process of reconciliation. Pres Bush is using Gen Patraeus and this hoopla surrounding this “Magic September” to redefine the mission again. The President is also trying to avoid his responsibility for the disastrous policies in Iraq by trying to hide behind his field commanders. As the New York Times points out, this is President Bush’s war, he started it, he planned it or failed to plan for it and he is responsible for it.
President Bush, however, seems to be aiming for maximum political advantage — not maximum clarity on Iraq’s military and political crises, which cannot be separated from each other. Mr. Bush, we fear, isn’t looking for the truth, only for ways to confound the public, scare Democrats into dropping their demands for a sound exit strategy, and prolong the war until he leaves office. At times, General Petraeus gives the disturbing impression that he, too, is more focused on the political game in Washington than the unfolding disaster in Iraq. That serves neither American nor Iraqi interests.
Mr. Bush, deeply unpopular with the American people, is counting on the general to restore credibility to his discredited Iraq policy. He frequently refers to the escalation of American forces last January as General Petraeus’s strategy — as if it were not his own creation. The situation echoes the way Mr. Bush made Colin Powell — another military man with an overly honed sense of a soldier’s duty — play frontman at the United Nations in 2003 to make the case that Iraq had weapons of mass destruction. Mr. Bush cannot once again subcontract his responsibility. This is his war.

6 Comments
New comments for this entry are closed.
Senator Kerry is right with his assessment. This is a stall tactic which is designed to cause a distraction and delay from the real focus here. Previous funding was given on the notion of setting benchmarks, which the Iraqis themselves picked. Now, they have simply failed to meet the benchmarks; and the Administration, who committed to use the benchmarks as important, now play down their significance. We need to stop hanging around in Iraq and go after the terrorists hard in Afghanistan. Our troops deserve a policy that we can succeed with. We are refereeing a civil war….I am sure the contractors such as Blackwater and Halliburton like it because it is a long term opportunity for them to make millions of tax payer money with little or no results to show? Cut the funding.
Senator Kerry was excellent on This Week this morning. I’m so glad he came on after McCain and told the American people the truth.
You are so right, this is Bush’s war always has been always will be. I read where Bush never told Colin Powell about the intelligence saying that there were no WMDs. So knowing that now I can see how Senator Kerry took Colin Powell’s word when he spoke with him before that vote, Colin Powell was being honest to Senator Kerry and I think if he knew about that intelligence he would have told Seantor Kerry straight up. You know I think everything is out on how this President lied us into war and more and more evidence comes out to show just how despicable he is.
Great post Terri. It sounds like President Bush may be suffering from ADD (Attention Deficit Disorder).No offense meant to anyone actually suffering from this disorder. Howerver, it does appear Mr. Bush can’t stay on task and he keeps wandering away from the real goals for Iraq. It is shameful actually, that he continues to view this whole conflict in political terms and refuses to either not accept or not acknowledge that military victories alone in Iraq will not bring the necessary and lasting stability the country needs to survive. How very tragic this all is for our soldiers,the Iraqi’s and the American people.
Moving of the goal post is right. Truly remarkable the testimony today of General Petraeus and Ambassador Crocker wherein Petraeus talks about tactical military “success” and Crocker misleads the public on the political side. To pretend the “agreement” Maliki and his government came up with on 8/26/07 was anything more than window dressing is ridiculous. The Sunnis in the parliament immediately rejected that agreement. I do not understand why Crocker wasn’t more forthright.
I actually saw this one, the first appearance by John Kerry I have watched in over a year. It was a good contact-point for me. The video is also telling just on a quick glance of the opening segment. I don’t have my sound system up so there is no sense is my watching it. But the message couldn’t be more clear.
The title of your posting is excellent, Terri: “Moving the goalposts again.” And there is the same basic idea in Dave Counts’s contribution with the notion of drawn lines. I like to think of them as boundaries. And that is something we certainly could use a lot more of. And it is also not so much charming as a better understanding to make the connections, especially for women, so that we understand a little better the correspondence between “goalposts” in athletics and sports and “boundaries” as they apply to women. And men, too, of course. And drawn lines as well. And lawns. That’s just for the landscapers outside who are busy working as I write this.
Anyway, more later.
Senate Kerry is right about Iraq. I am thankful he has patriotism to our Country above politics. He sees the reality going on in Iraq and Washington. He has the strength in guide this war to a conclusion and speaks the truth to the American people. We should all support him as he has the ability to understand and the courage to advance the best interests for our Country and the region. Both dems and republicans are afraid to face responsibility. Senate John Kerry should take the lead publicly explaining to the American people what is going on, and if the other dems and republicans don’t want to go along, then they should get out of his way.
The Generals should answer to the people and Congress not the other way around. They must respect us as much as we respect them.