Senate Debates Troop Withdrawal from Iraq - UPDATED
This comes in the way of a little “we told you so” or “we’ve been saying that all along” but admittedly, it is nice to see it in print.
Dems’ Iraq Plan Looks Familiar to John Kerry Similar Plan to Senator’s Proposal in October 2005
Allies of Sen. John Kerry, D-Mass., point out that the current withdrawal (or “phased redeployment”) proposal introduced last week by Senate Democratic leaders and currently being debated on the floor of the U.S. Senate greatly resembles plans Kerry introduced in October 2005 as well as in June 2006.
Moreover, they note
- with regret in their voice and bile in their mouths -for his efforts at the time Kerry and his plan were mocked and belittled by his fellow Democratic senators, at least one of whom joined Kerry at a press conference today to push the new proposal....
Asked after the press conference if Reid’s plan wasn’t the same as his from last June, Kerry smiles and said, “They’re very similar.”
So what took his colleagues so long to come to the conclusion he reached about a “phased redeployment” back in October 2005?
“These things take time,” Kerry said. “Things have to percolate. That’s the nature of legislation.”
...
Asked today about the lack of support
- and anonymous sniping -he experienced back then from the same Democratic senators he stood with today, Kerry said “I’m not interested in going backwards.”He then resisted one more effort by this reporter to prod him into a more emotive response, smiled, and walked off.
Enjoy your reading!

10 Comments
New comments for this entry are closed.
This is welcomed progress. It’s imperative that Congress sets a deadline to get the troops out of Iraq safely and as soon as possible, and address the what next. The U.S. isn’t going to withdraw from the international community when combat troops exit Iraq. Senator Kerry has long advocated a plan calling for a deadline and diplomacy.
Here’s a great photo from today’s press conference.
This part was excellent:
This new ‘surge’ is just a second helping of the same old dish. There’s a word for this kind creeping escalation: Vietnam. This is exactly the kind of steady escalation that got tens of thousands of American soldiers killed for a policy that could not work.
I want to note here that NPR yesterday (or perhaps on Monday) reported that the newest supplemental funding request includes a request for an addition 3500 troops for Afghanistan and inserted discreetly throughout the bill, requests for what amounts to another 6000 new troops for Iraq, that would be in addition to the 21,000 already requested for the surge.
I haven’t seen that noted elsewhere in MSM though I haven’t looked too hard for it. Anyone else hear or see anything about that?
Olbermann and others have been covering it for the last couple or three days. While the MSM isn’t exactly trumpeting it from the rooftops, it’s not a hidden story either. Sure looks from here like the current administration’s lockstep lead on the MSM’s nosering is history by now.
It will still be tough to pass this resolution, but they are so much closer than when Senator Kerry and 12 brave Senators stood for setting a deadline about 9 months ago. I remember that Senator Warner then told Senator Kerry that timing is everything- I hope the timing will be right now for a few Republicans to vote for this.
The reasons given for this amendment are exactly those laid out by Senator Kerry last year - he was the one with the right timing. Had President Bush accepted the Senators plan, we would nearly out of Iraq by now and with any luck the recommended diplomatic initiatives would have led to a better situation.
It would be nice if the other Senators gave Senator Kerry more credit, but the important thing is that this is moving forward and has gained strength.
Here is a clip of the news conference: http://democrats.senate.gov/multimedia
Too bad that the resolution does not include a firm deadline (as recognized by Kerry in a short blurb I heard on NPR) and that we need to wait 120 days before withdrawing.
But it is a clear progress compared to what exists and clearly a challenge to get nearly all the Democrats united on a statement for withdrawal.
John Kerry did what he said he would do. He got the resolution for setting a deadline on the Senate agenda again. He came through for us and the rest of the American people.
So now it is time for us to really support this effort and reach out to both republicans and democrats to stop with the politics and seriously suport a plan that will get Iraq to pull together.
And in the meanwhile, the New York Times reports that the Iraqi government has already failed to meet the timetables and requirements that the administration presented to Congress months ago:
Well that was a quick debate.
When I got home I learned that the whole debate and voting on the Iraq War resoultion was over.
The Senators are still barking at each other and don’t understand the urgency of creating a Iraq policy that will have results for the Iraq people, our soliders and our national interest
I don’t think the republican senators want to debate, they rather call the democrats names. They don’t know how to do the hard work.
Thank goodness for John Kerry. He is willing to do the work for a solution to the Iraq war and he will always look out for the welfare of our soliders. They should know by now that John Kerry will never forget that they are out there in Iraq and will be sure they are appreciated now and when they come home. While everyone esle is distracted by politics (including the media) John Kerry keeps focused.