The Importance of Diplomacy

Being willing to talk to your adversaries is a sign of well-grounded diplomacy. JK made some clear statements this week about the importance of diplomacy on a region-wide basis in the Middle East.

Interview with David Gregory on the Today Show: [ transcript | video ]

The fundamental resolution that I’ve heard in every country I’ve been to - I’ve been to Egypt - I met with President Mubarak; I’ve been to Jordan - met with King Abdullah yesterday; we’re here in Syria today; going to Israel from here; I was in Lebanon yesterday - everywhere people are saying, “You’ve got to have a comprehensive political reconciliation process.” And we’re here to explore whether that can be broader than it’s been in the past and we think it can.

[...]

But nothing is going to resolve Iraq without this fundamental political reconciliation. You have a divide between Sunni and Shia. And you have criminal elements. You have ex-Baathist elements. You’ve just got an enormous historical cultural problem. And the only way to overcome it is with major assistance from outside countries and from us to get that political resolution.

[...]

And I’ll tell you, right out here in the Middle East, David, this is more of a tinderbox than a lot of people are focused on.

The Boston Globe article on 12-21-2005:

“He [President Assad] offered some very direct and concrete ways in which they could be helpful in Iraq,” Kerry said in an interview conducted by telephone from Damascus. “I came away with a distinct feeling that there are opportunities here. There are fronts in which we can work together if people are inclined to.”

Kerry said the Assad government is interested in approaching the Iraq war from a regional perspective, where other Middle East issues - including the Israeli Palestinian conflict—are part of the equation.

[...]

“I think you’ve got to talk with people,” Kerry said. “You can disagree with them and disagree with them and disagree with them, and you may not get anywhere, but you’ve got to talk to people.”

Interview with Alex Chadwick on NPR’s Day-To-Day program: [ transcript | audio ]

And the fact is I think there are very real possibilities that Senator Dodd and I will certainly relate to the Administration that we think they can follow up on and they could conceivably elicit some great cooperation. I believe that possibility is real. And I think that they certainly spoke clearly, definitively and specifically about the way they’re prepared to do things with respect to Iraq and how important they think it is that there be a regional-wide effort.

[...]

Ronald Reagan talked to Gorbachev. Richard Nixon sent Kissinger to talk to the Chinese. We need to engage. This is too dangerous a world not to. And …we’re trying to help the administration and I think they will be pleased with today’s discussion, I really do.

<!-more->  

As Kerry notes, the diplomatic situation in the Middle East is extremely complex and dynamic. To help you keep up, here are some other related items that will be of interest to those following JK’s travels closely.

Daniel Levy at the Huffington Post highlights interactions with Syria including the discussion in Israel that resulted from Olmert’s comments on the ISG report, the Syrian offer to meet and the Syrian visit of Senators Kerry and Dodd. He noted, “In Israel, this all set off a heated and almost unprecedented debate on the current state of Israeli-American relations.”

Time Magazine has a remarkable exclusive report about the Bush Administration’s efforts to “quietly nurtur[e] individuals and parties opposed to the Syrian government in an effort to undermine the regime of President Bashar Assad. Parts of the scheme are outlined in a classified, two-page document which says that the U.S. already is “supporting regular meetings of internal and diaspora Syrian activists” in Europe.”

Steve Clemons recounts an interesting comment from a UAE official in a meeting he participated in which affirms the message of region-wide diplomacy in the face of thwarting terrorism wherever it appears.

The Iraq Study Group report: see recommendations 15 and 16 for the Baker-Hamilton Commission’s proposed approach of diplomatic re-engagement.

The New York Times reference page on Syria

UPDATE: Just uncovered this article from The Nation by a US Special Forces officer, Major Bill Edmonds, who served in Iraq. It affirms on a retail level, the importance of diplomacy and the weakness of a military solution that is not accompanied by a vigorous political and diplomatic effort. With a hat-tip to L.C. Johnson at No Quarter, here is the introduction of a tale that should be required reading.

For just a minute or two, step into my life. I am an American soldier in the Army Special Forces. I have just returned from a one-year tour of duty in Iraq, where I lived, shared meals, slept and fought beside my Iraqi counterpart as we battled insurgents in the center of a thousand-year-old city. I am a conflicted man, and I want you to read the story of that experience as I lived it. In the interest of security, I have omitted some identifying details, but every word is true.

 

5 Comments

New comments for this entry are closed.

Wow, Violet, there is a lot there in those links. The last one, from the Special Forces officer, is very compelling.

The situation in the ME just seems to be getting worse with every day that Bush is in office.  I am glad for what Senator Kerry is doing to create dialog and make it clear we aren’t all idiots, but I confess that I fear Bush will undo every good thing that Kerry and others like him try to do.

Posted by MH | 12/22/06, 04:58 PM EST

The last link says it all. In “Tour of Duty” John Kerry says “we haven’t learned our lessons”, he was so right.

Five more soldiers died today, which must be especially hard on their loved ones during this holiday season. My heart goes out to their families.

Posted by fedup | 12/22/06, 06:13 PM EST

I ran across an interesting article at IPS about an effort undertaken by many countries, to try to build an “Alliance of Civilizations” rather than having a “clash of civilizations.” On the AoC website there is a page listing the ”Group of Friends” consisting of “governments and multilateral organizations that support the efforts of the Alliance of Civilizations to counter the rise of extremism and polarization.” The UK, Mexico, and other western nations are listed along with many from the Middle East. But, neither the U.S. or Canada are listed.  I think that’s really unfortunate, and I suspect if we had a Democratic President - a real Democrat, like John Kerry - our government would be participating in efforts like this.

I have some additional commentary about the article at my blog.

Posted by MH | 12/22/06, 06:19 PM EST

MH,
Thank you SO much for posting the information about the Alliance of Civilizations. A timely ray of hope to brighten the season, and the turn of the year.

Posted by mbk | 12/23/06, 02:51 AM EST

We also have to get the American people to understand that we’ve got to listen.  We can’t keep tearing countries apart every time a terrorist group pops up in one of them.  This has just been an entirely catastrophic approach to the problem.  Good to see Senator Kerry is staying right on the war, we’ve got to end this madness.

On a side note - Merry Christmas & Happy Holidays everybody!

Posted by Sandy | 12/23/06, 08:01 AM EST
Join JohnKerry.com
Contribute
Help us fight for a new direction for our country. Make a contribution today.
Contribute
Volunteer

Imagine what we can accomplish together.


Email volunteer@johnkerry.com and tell Terri you want to volunteer!

Recent News
Recent Blog Posts